Sunday, March 27, 2011

Blog Entry #10: Classification of Noir

    Two out the four stories that I have read I found very interesting. I believe that from all the Los Angeles stories that I’ve read they all seem to fall under the noir category. The main story that I found that is an example of noir would be Kinship by Brian Ascalon Roley. Mainly I choose this story as a classification as noir just because of what happens at the end of the novel when Veronicas cousin decided to stick in an ice pick into the man that did damage to Emerson. As a proof that I feel that it’s somewhat related to noir would be when in the novel it states ‘I am a father too, I said loudly enough for Manny to hear, and then I reached down and stuck him’ (pg. 317). As for this statement it relates to noir because back then all the violence involved a lot of weapons than today’s time. Even in today’s time there are still weapons involved but not as many as before. The novel that I found difficult to classify as noir was the novel What You See by Diana Wagman. The reason that I had found this novel difficult to classify as noir is because how the narrator wrote it. In the novel What You See it seemed easier to classify it as if it were to be a horror type of novel and being able to visualize it as a horror film by the way the story ended. This novel actually wouldn’t fit with noir. The narrator describes the things and places very well but I wouldn’t classify it as noir.

2 comments:

  1. Hello!! i agree with you about the story What You See by Diana Wagman, i di dhave a very good description but i did not find manny elements of noir to classify it. on the other hand In my blog i stated that Kinship is not Noir, but as i refelcted it has many element such as Flashbacks that are mostly the whole story and the evil and arms as you said... very good job and keep up Jazmin :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Jazmin, it was really wonderful to read something that is totally different than what I have thought. I selected "Barnaby Jones" as full of the most noir elements.But, after reading your blog, I have noticed that, your selection the most noir elements in Kinship is also right; since it is a story of a gang member, murders and other dark sides of human nature. What you see is a non-noir story, that I have found out by reading your blog. Thank you for that and keep up the good work.

    ReplyDelete